Defining Success
Sometime before summertime, Elsie came home from school beaming about her day. When I pick her up, I always ask her the same question and she always answers the same way. It’s become a fun, weird tradition that I look forward to, but I guess that’s the very definition of a tradition.
I ask her to tell me three things about her day, hoping for specifics.
She shares with me, It was fine, it was good, it was fun. No specifics.
We both laugh and then on this day, she tells me that during P.E., they played softball and she hit a home run and it was the BEST DAY EVER. She asked that when it’s time to sign up for softball, could I please please please sign her up because it’s her new favorite thing.
So, I watched the interwebs for fall ball signup and found a league and a team and I paid the registration fees and we chose her jersey number (98) and we headed to the sporting goods store to buy a glove and balls and a facemask and a helmet and a bat and pants and socks. We bought the wrong size bat so we went back another time for the right size.
We showed up to her first practice and we didn’t know anyone. Elsie joined the other girls, all who knew each other from previous years of playing the game, in the dugout to meet the coach. They practiced hitting and throwing and catching and it all seemed okay. It was okay. We went back to practice again and learned sliding and stealing bases. It was okay too. Elsie made friends with a couple of girls and we were looking forward to their first game.
And then it was game day and it suddenly wasn’t okay.
Anxiety crept in and we thought about not going to the game (a double-header). And after a lot of talking and a really supportive coach, Elsie decided she’d go to the game, sit with the team, and see how it all felt. Afterward, she could decide if she wanted to keep playing or not, and that it was totally up to her but she had to see at least this part through.
She ended up playing outfield in the second game and left the field confident and beaming - just like she did on that day after P.E.
We got cotton-candy flavored ice cream to celebrate and I was so proud. We persevered. We did it. We succeeded. We’re doing this softball thing. We made it through the tough stuff together.
We did it.
And then it came time for practice the next week and Elsie looked me right in the eyes and made the decision that softball wasn’t her thing and she didn’t want to go back.
My heart sunk.
We failed.
I failed.
I failed her.
I asked if she was sure, and she was sure. I asked her again, and she was still sure. And my heart stayed heavy because failure feels bad.
But then I wondered, why is it a failure? Even though we didn’t make it back to the dugout, she did a lot that I’m so proud of.
She found out something new to try.
She walked into a gaggle of girls and made friends.
She faced her fears.
She was able to tell me the truth.
She was empowered to make her own choice and she did.
So, it’s time for me to redefine success and redefine failure. Success isn’t the outcome and for us. Success isn’t hitting a grand slam or sticking with the game or sliding into home. Success for her right now is finding herself outside her comfort zone and taking small steps and big ones too to figure out who she is and what she likes and feeling brave enough to hit the brake pedal when she needs to.
Failure is doing something you don’t want to be doing. Failure is being afraid to say when things are feeling like too much. Failure is keeping your inner voice quiet.
Failure is not trusting your instincts.
So, I’m sitting here thinking that I’m going to get comfortable living sweetly in the success of a nine-year-old girl who is getting to know herself because that’s really her one and only job, and my job as her mom is to be here to cheer her on from whatever sideline I find myself cheering from.
XO